top of page

Book Review: Lead with a Story by Paul Smith - Getting SEO Buy-In

This is one that it looks like I had in my Audible purchase history ...


but I can't find it now in my account to review. So I'm going to use AI here to pull out the key threads and then I'll weave them into an SEO story (pun intended). I can't imagine I returned it ...


I'm sure we've all heard of the concept of "moving from strings to things", there's a similar evolution you are likely to be going through as you progress in your career: from tactics to strategies. As you progress up through the corporate ladder a similar shift in competencies from explaining opportunities at a tactical level to strategic and that is best served by the concept of storytelling. This is the skill of being able to weave opportunities and resource alignment into a narrative. Reading the book 'Lead with a Story' by Paul Smith can definitely help SEOs better understand the why and the how of getting SEO buy-in.



The Pillars of Narrative Influence:

Before dissecting specific insights, let's solidify our understanding of Smith's core principles:

  • The Power of Narrative: Stories resonate with us on a deeper level, bypassing logic and tapping into emotions. Weaving narratives into your SEO strategy and how you socialise it fosters connection, builds trust, and motivates users to engage with your content and personal-brand. Don't just don't think of this as a book to help with external manifestation, but also internal to the organisation. And vice-versa.

  • Structure for Impact: Smith provides a clear six-part story structure – Situation, Complication, Question, Answer, Action, and Outcome – that can be applied to website copy, landing pages, even blog posts and forming strategies. This structure ensures your SEO content is engaging, memorable, and drives users towards a desired action.

  • Authenticity Matters: Don't fabricate tales or force narratives. Find the genuine stories that resonate with your brand and target audience. Authentic narratives build trust, foster emotional connection, and make your SEO efforts feel human and relatable.

  • Data as Your Compass: While "Lead with a Story" emphasises empathy and connection, data analytics remains crucial. Track audience engagement with your content, identify which narratives resonate best, and use data to refine your storytelling approach for optimal SEO impact.

Unleashing the Narrative Power: SEO Strategies that Captivate:

Now, let's turn theory into practice and explore how to apply Smith's framework to specific SEO aspects:

1. Crafting Compelling Content:

  • Infuse Stories into Blog Posts and Articles: Don't just write individual, stand-alone informative pieces; use personal anecdotes, case studies, and customer testimonials to weave narratives that illustrate your points and resonate with readers. This enhances engagement, increases dwell time, and encourages social sharing, potentially boosting organic reach. Internally, have a central theme that runs through what you communicate. That north star metric should be central most of your communications 'up and out'.

  • Create Landing Pages that Convert: If you can scale it, ditch dry product descriptions and replace them with compelling narratives that explain your value proposition and address user pain points. Use the six-part story structure to create engaging landing pages that guide users towards desired actions, improving conversion rates and organic traffic quality.

  • Develop a Branded Narrative: Craft a narrative that defines your brand's values, mission, and unique selling proposition. Integrate this narrative into your website copy, social media presence, and even email marketing campaigns. A strong brand story builds trust, fosters brand loyalty, and can indirectly influence SEO factors like click-through rates and search engine trust.

2. Building Bridges with Internal Linking:

  • Narratively-Driven Link Anchor Text: Instead of generic keywords, use evocative anchor text that hints at the story users will find on the linked page. This triggers curiosity, encourages exploration, and improves user experience, potentially increasing dwell time and click-through rates on internal links. This approach takes you away from the purest sense of exact-match anchor text, but there's definitely value here

  • Thematic Link Clusters: Group related content pages based on shared narratives or themes. This not only enhances user experience but also strengthens internal linking structure, signaling relevance to search engines and potentially impacting keyword rankings. Take a look at this Majestic blog post to learn more about reading link data.

  • Interactive Storytelling with Case Studies: If relevant, don't just list project results; create interactive case studies that tell the story of your collaboration with a client. Include challenges overcome, lessons learned, and impactful outcomes. This engaging narrative showcases your expertise, builds trust, and can attract potential leads, impacting organic reach and brand awareness.

3. Engaging Your Audience with Social Media:

  • The Power of Micro-Stories: Share impactful snippets of customer testimonials, employee experiences, or even brand origin stories on your social media platforms. These micro-stories pique user interest, encourage engagement, and drive traffic back to your website, potentially boosting organic reach and search engine trust.

  • Leverage User-Generated Content: Encourage customers to share their experiences and stories related to your brand on social media using specific hashtags or challenges. This user-generated content taps into the social proof principle, builds trust, and expands your organic reach without relying solely on SEO tactics.

  • Run Interactive Storytelling Campaigns: Utilize interactive elements like polls, quizzes, or even choose-your-own-adventure narratives within your social media campaigns. This keeps users engaged, collects valuable data on their preferences, and can strengthen brand recall, potentially impacting organic visibility in the long run.

4. Data: Your Storytelling Compass:

  • Track User Engagement Metrics: Monitor how users interact with your narrative-driven content. Analyze bounce rates, dwell time, social shares, and conversions to understand what resonates with your audience and what falls flat. Use this data to refine your storytelling approach and create content that genuinely connects.

  • Experiment with Different Narrative Structures: Not every story format works for every audience. Test various storytelling techniques, such as hero's journey, problem-solution, or even humorous anecdotes, to see what engages your target demographic. Data-driven experimentation ensures you're crafting the most effective narratives for your SEO goals.

  • Collect Qualitative Feedback: Gather user feedback through surveys, comments, or social media interactions to gain insights into their emotional responses to your stories. Understand what evokes laughter, tears, or inspiration, and use this knowledge to craft even more impactful content that resonates deeply with your audience.

  • Measure Impact on Organic Traffic and Rankings: Track how your narrative-driven SEO efforts affect organic traffic, keyword rankings, and overall search visibility. This data helps you quantify the effectiveness of storytelling and demonstrate its tangible value for your SEO strategy, justifying continued investment in this approach.

Beyond Tactics: Building an Authentic SEO Narrative:

"Lead with a Story" isn't just a toolkit of techniques; it's a mindset shift. By embracing storytelling as a core element of your SEO strategy, you can create content that not only ranks well but also genuinely connects with your audience, fostering trust, loyalty, and ultimately, driving meaningful results. Remember:

  • Authenticity Is Key: Don't force stories that don't align with your brand or values. Find the authentic narratives that represent your unique identity and resonate with your target audience. This genuine approach builds trust and fosters long-term relationships with users.

  • Emotions Drive Action: Tap into the emotional power of storytelling to motivate users to take action, whether it's subscribing to your newsletter, sharing your content, or making a purchase. Stories that evoke laughter, empathy, or inspiration are more likely to prompt engagement and conversions.

  • Build a Community of Storytellers: Empower your employees, customers, and partners to share their experiences and stories related to your brand. This creates a rich tapestry of narratives that amplifies your brand voice, expands your reach, and builds a sense of community around your SEO efforts.


You can get this book here from Amazon (aff). I'd give it a 6/10 to return to, but I feel there are probably more recent books that should be explored first.

bottom of page